Once you have your hands on an active mother, you can experiment with all the flavors available to you. The vinegar making process is extremely tolerant and it turns out alright without too much fuss. Out of laziness, I don't measure and tend to mix more by taste as I vary the ingredients depending on how intense I want the vinegar to turn out. Sometimes I will make a batch as small as a jam jar mostly to experiment with intensity. There exists a myriad ways of making vinegar but I tend to make micro-batches with high-end ingredients and the instructions below reflect just a rough guideline on how to make such a recipe.
I normally throw the following four ingredients into a wide mouthed glass jar:
My most successful variations have been:
I normally throw the following four ingredients into a wide mouthed glass jar:
- Flavor base like a sweet syrup - You can start with raw fruits like pineapple or apple but I tend to favor fruit syrups (i.e. Elderberry Syrup/Lingonberry Syrup) as the base as the resulting vinegars come out more intense. The sugars have to convert to alcohol and then to vinegar.
- Liquor - Since I'm going for quality, I tend to use specialized liquors like Elderberry Liquor or Creme de Cassis but you can also use cheap amaretto and rum with good results.
- Water - I use anywhere between 1-1 to 2-1 water to syrup ratio. Some berry syrups can become too bitter at full strength.
- Mother -You can put a tiny square inch of mother, a spoonful of gunk, or sheets of it which will greatly accelerate the conversion.
My most successful variations have been:
- Double Elderberry Flower - Ikea Elderberry Syrup + St. Germain Elderberry Liquer : Best with fruit salads, esp. citrus and shaved fennel
- Double Berry - IKEA Lingonberry Syrup + Creme de Cassis - Fabulous with beet salads
- Carob Syrup + Rum - cracking with with persimmon salad.
- Apricot + Amaretto - boxed Apricot Juice + cheap Trader Joe's Amaretto.
- buckwheat honey - just not as deep tasting as the carob syrup
- lavender honey + rum - good but not great
- pomegranate syrup + rum
- blueberry syrup - good but not as interesting as lingonberry
- wine - tastes like vinegar but kind of uninteresting compared to fruit syrups
- honey + sake- sake makes the vinegar taste flat and thin
- pineapple - tangy but too harsh and boring compared to the fruit syrup vinegars
- old raisins - prison hooch
- molasses - a little bitter
- brandy - not worth the end product